Announcements
- EXTRA CREDIT: International Film
- Margherita delle Stelle (2024)
- Thursday, Nov. 19th, 5:30-7:30pm
- Smith 204
- Refreshments Served (not sure what…probably no vino)
- Discussion Post #10 due this week–last one of the semester
- Heads up on Lewis F. Powell, Jr.’s “The Memo” (1971)
Plan for the Day
- Finish up our discussion on Dwight D. Eisenhower
- Brief History of Labor Movements in the United States
- César Chávez
- Democracy/Liberty/Freedom/ETC. quotation:
“We must understand that the highest form of freedom carries with it the greatest measure of discipline.”
—Cesar Chavez. “Aphorisms.” An Organizer’s Tale: Speeches. Edited by Ilan Stavans. Penguin, 2008, pp. 235-236.
History of Labor: Rights, Power, Freedom
Although I mention above that we’ll discuss Labor History in the United States, I’m backing up a bit to show how long human civilization has organized and tried to codify labor membership and rules. It makes sense that people would organize around their employment and want to maintain proper wages as well as the vetting system of new skilled tradespeople. Today, we have unions and industry organizations that advocate for workers, and many of them are international organizations. These organizations are massive compared to the local groups that banded together.
Minimum Wage, Guilds, and Incorporated Towns
One of civilization’s oldest known legal codes specifies payment for specific commercial endeavors: The Babylonian Code of Hammurabi (1755–1750 BCE). The code is quite detailed and justified by Hammurabi, who claims, “I am Hammurabi, king of justice, to whom the god Shamash has granted (insight into) the truth” (Roth 135). The Code specifies the following:
- “¶ 257 If a man hires an agricultural laborer, he shall give him 2,400 silas of grain per year.” (Roth 129)
- “¶ 261 If a man hires a herdsman to herd cattle or the sheep and, he shall give him 2,400 silas of grain per year.” (Roth 129)
- “¶ 274 If a man intends to hire a craftsman, he shall give, per [day]: as the hire of a …, 5 barleycorns of silver; as the hire of a woven-textile worker, 5 barleycorns of silver; as the hire of linen-worker…” (Roth 131)
Even in Ancient Mesopotamia, there were attempts to standardize payment for goods and services. There’s also a suggestion that professional standards (“being up to code”) were practiced and regulated:
- “¶ 228 If a builder constructs a house for a man to his satisfaction, he shall give him 2 shekels of silver for each sar of house as his compensation.
- “¶ 229 If a builder constructs a house for a man but does not make his work sound, and the house that he constructs collapses and causes the death of the householder, that builder shall be killed.”
- “¶ 230 If it should cause the death of a son of the householder, they shall kill a son of that builder.”
- “¶ 231 If it should cause the death of a slave of the householder, he shall give to the householder a slave of comparable value for the slave.” (Roth 125)
We’re a long way from thinking about the hourly minimum wage and the actual conditions of this work, but we have a legal basis for “just” compensation.
Guilds
Guilds are groups of skilled craftsmen and merchants, and they have a long history. In addition to guilds standardizing measurements from Ancient Mesopotamia, guilds existed in Ancient Rome, but we often jump to the Medieval Guilds of Europe to lay the foundations of organized Labor in the 19th, 20th, and 21st centuries. Guilds of Medieval Europe had support of the Church, and flourished among Germanic and English groups. Because of our focus, we’ll draw a line from there to post-WWII American Unions. Some important aspects of these Medieval Guilds:
- “Accredited” the process of progression: apprentice, craftsman, journeyman, and master (even grandmaster)
- Codes/Standards for work
- Set boundaries for areas of commerce
- Settled disputes among members
- Safey net for elderly or injured members (and families)
The Oxford English Dictionary (available on campus and when signed into Atkins off campus) has both definitions and a nice history in its entry on “guilds.” QUESTIONS
- So what? Why are Labor issues a concern of the State?
- How is Labor implicated in engaging with American democracy?
United States Labor History
There were “guilds” and professional organizations before the United States was established. These groups were organized around occupation. We often point to the rise of the Industrial Revolution as a starting point for our sense of Unions today. One of the first groups to strike were the Cordwainers (shoemakers and leather workers) in 1804. Interestingly, unions were “legalized” (or had the beginning of a legal basis) in a Massachusetts Supreme Court case Commonwealth v. Hunt (1842). However, union members (especially the leaders) were at risk of the following:
- Seen as thwarting private enterprise
- Convicted of conspiracy
- Heavy fines
The Labor movement in the United States is not all picket lines of workers on strike. There was a lot of violence that eventually led to better working conditions codified in law. Here are a few to consider:
- Great Railroad Strike of 1877 (West Virginia & Maryland) Railroad workers went on strike (for 52 days–more than Congress’s “strike”) because their wages were cut by the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad (B&O). The workers weren’t in a union, but they were a collective. The workers didn’t allow any goods to be transported, so the National Guard was brought in. The unrest spread to several states, and many people were killed.
- Haymarket Affair (Chicago 1886) What began as a protest for an 8-hour workday (which seems a bit long), literally blew up: Someone threw a stick of dynamite after police fired into a crowd of rioters who were storming the gates of the McCormick Harvesting Machine Company. Local anarchists were arrested, and the public turned against unions and German immigrants.
- Homestead Strike (near Pittsburg 1892) Pennsylvania steel workers, specifically members of the Amalgamated Association of Iron and Steel Workers (AAISW), went on strike to protest Carnegie Steel Company’s wage cuts while the Company made record profits. Pinkerton agents tried to squash the strikers, but they were stopped, and people were killed on both sides. The National Guard came in and ended the strike. AAISW disbanded.
- Homestead Strike video
- Pullman Strike (Chicago 1894) Railway Union members went on strike and called for a boycott against the Pullman Company for refusing to recognize the American Railway Union (ARU) headed by Eugene V. Debs. Riots broke out and people were killed, which led President Grover Cleveland to send in the Army. The strike went around the country and was unpopular with the public. Debs went to prison, and the ARU was disbanded, but Debs would eventually return.
- International Association of Bridge Structural Iron Workers (1906-1911) This group decided to dynamite sites (bridges, factories, warehouses, etc.) that were “open shops,” ones that prohibited or didn’t require union membership to work. This is more terrorism than “protest,” but it shows how violent Labor got.
- Fred Erwin Beal was arrested and convicted of conspiracy in Gastonia, NC, in 1929. He fled to Stalin’s Soviet Union but became disillusioned with socialism after seeing the horrors of Stalin’s policies.
Marxist Theory — Texts and Contexts are Social Constructions
I wanted to make sure we’re on the same page about why I bring up M/marxism during a discussion on labor and ideology. As a literary theory, Marxism is a 20th-Century development influenced by the writings of the 19th-Century philosophers Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. At a basic level (again, we could go into more detail), Marxist analysis “focus[es] on the study of the relationship between a text and the society that reads it” (Bressler, p. 193). Another core Marxist principle is the idea of reality or consciousness: cultural analysis, our focus in this course, is intertwined with the idea that “[a] person’s consciousness is not shaped by any spiritual entity; through daily living and interacting with each other, humans define themselves” (Bressler, p. 193). Marx and Engels, products of newly industrialized/ing cultures, critique industrial society and theorize the following two tenets of industrial society: base and superstructure.
- Base: “the economic means of production within a society” (Bressler, p. 193); think capital, land, wealth, etc.
- Superstructure: the institutions and ideologies of a society that “develop as a direct result of the economic means of production, not the other way around” (Bressler, p. 193).
It’s important to understand the difficulty of critiquing a culture that one belongs to because there’s little chance for critical distance. We (humans in general) like to believe culture is absolute and not relative to the social conditions in which we interact or, in Marxist terms, the economic system in which we exist. For example, capitalism is pervasive in American culture and the “free” market is seen as the only appropriate way to organize or distribute resources. Therefore, the means of production and who owns those means influence the ways in which institutions form.
César E. Chávez’s “United We Shall Stand: Delano Manifesto” (1966)
This is a short piece, but it requires the context of the labor movement in the United States. Grape workers (California wine and table grapes), with support of farm workers across California, went on strike. This went on for several years: Remembering Delano’s Historic Grape Strike (video).
Eventually, California would pass the Agricultural Labor Relations Act (ALRA) in 1975. One specific component of the ALRA is that “it provides agricultural unions with an additional bargaining tool by allowing the unions, under the conditions specified in the Act, to bring indirect pressure on a primary employer by requesting that the public not patronize the neutral who is doing business with the primary” (Levy 793)
The Rhetoric of the Manifesto
I wanted you to see the “poster” of the excerpted El Plan de Delano, so you can feel the force it has. The full version is here (PDF). Consider the effect of the following:
- para. 1: “We seek our basic, God-given rights as human beings.”
- “We shall do it without violence because that is our destiny.”
- para. 2: “We know why these United States are just that–united.”
- “The strength of the poor is also a union.
- para. 3: “…bargain collectively. We must use the only strength that we have, the force of our numbers….UNITED WE SHALL STAND.”
- para. 4: Repetition of “we do not want” that leads to a contrast.
- “We do not want the paternalism of the rancher; we do not want the contractor, we do not want charity at the price of our dignity.”
- “We want to be equal…”
- “WE SHALL OVERCOME.”
More resources and background on this strike:
- Huerta, Dolores. “Proclamation of the Delano Grape Workers for International Boycott Day” (10 May 1969)
- Yesterday, 11/16/2026, she lay in State at the California Capitol
- National Park Service. “Mobilizing Support for La Causa”
- AFL-CIO’s César Chávez Bio
By 1969, the boycott had stopped the sales of California table grapes in Detroit, Chicago, New York, Boston, Philadelphia, Montreal and Toronto. In July 1969, the Giumarra family told the union they wanted to sign a contract. They agreed to assemble the other 28 major grape growers, and, after three days of intense negotiations, the growers agreed to recognize the union, raise the grape pickers’ pay, create a hiring hall, set up a joint labor-management committee to regulate pesticide use and contribute to the farm workers’ health and welfare plan.”
“César Chávez.” AFL-CIO
Questions (time permitting)
- What types of boycotts (or buycotts) do you recognize contemporarily?
- Are boycotts (or buycotts) engaging with democracy?
- Do you think boycotts (or buycotts) are effective?
Next Class
We’ll finish up Eisenhower and Cesar E. Chavez’s “United We Shall Stand: Delano Manifesto” (1966) before moving onto the excerpt from Lewis F. Powell, Jr.’s “The Memo” (1971). Don’t forget to do Weekly Discussion #10 before Friday, 11/20, 11:07pm. It’s the last one of the semester!
Works Cited
Bressler, Charles E. Literary Criticism: An Introduction to Theory and Practice. (4th ed.) Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson, 2007.
Levy, Herman M. “The Agricultural Labor Relations Act of 1975 – La Esperanza De California Para El Futuro.” Santa Clara Lawyer, vol. 15, no. 4, 1975. Digital Commons
Roth, Martha Tobi. “Laws of Hammurabi.” Law Collections From Mesopotamia and Asia Minor. Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1997, pp. 71-142.